When Ava Mathias’ husband Zeke has his good friend, Samuel, drive him to Ohio for a new breeding puppy, the two young men find trouble. As a result they come home with more than just a puppy, which upsets Ava. Aunt Rachael throws a temper tantrum, or two. Isaac, Ava’s eldest brother, puts his foot down. Then Abe, Ava’s wayward brother, makes several different decisions, which surprises everyone, including Abe himself.